Tom Brady · Tier 1 · All-Time Greats
3 AP MVP awards (2007, 2010, 2017) and 7 Super Bowl wins as starting QB.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileEVIDENCE REGISTER · NOVEMBER 13, 2026
Each record below separates draft facts, scouting opinion and Combine data. Source quality varies. Missing original records remain open research tasks.
The current selected cohort contains 29 players: achievement-based Tiers 1–3 and Tier 4, My Eye-Test Guys. Andrew Luck, Trevor Lawrence and Kirk Cousins are explicitly subjective selections. This is an editorial framework, not an official NFL classification or validated predictive model.
Current descriptive cards and comparisons are recomputed for the selected 29-player cohort, including documented JUCO and postseason. The historical 20-player records below are retained only for source history. These patterns do not estimate NFL success probabilities.
nflverse dataset documentation · Source dataset
The original records are retained with their source history. The eight added players’ pre-NFL records are pending; see their profile for the achievement route.
| Player | Draft | Scouting | Combine |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aaron Rodgers | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcerepublished historical evaluator comments Page last updated July 22, 2022; original publication date unestablished | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Patrick Mahomes | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourceOriginal pre-draft PFF analysis 2017-03-14 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Peyton Manning | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcerepublished historical evaluator comments Page last updated July 22, 2022; original publication date unestablished | Combine recordOriginal reporter explicitly attributes height/weight to 1998 combine; later republication |
| Tom Brady | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcerepublished historical evaluator comments Page last updated July 22, 2022; original publication date unestablished | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Drew Brees | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcerepublished historical evaluator comments Page last updated July 22, 2022; original publication date unestablished | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Josh Allen | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourceOriginal contemporaneous team editorial profile by Craig Peters 2018-03-11 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Lamar Jackson | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourceContemporaneous team editorial profile quoting Lance Zierlein 2018-04-06 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Matt Ryan | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcecontemporaneous pre-draft team reporting, 2008-04-02 2008-04-02 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Matthew Stafford | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcerepublished historical evaluator comments Page last updated July 22, 2022; original publication date unestablished | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Ben Roethlisberger | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcecontemporaneous pre-draft reporting, 2004-02-20 2004-02-20 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Cam Newton | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcecontemporaneous pre-draft scouting, 2011-04-26 2011-04-26 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Donovan McNabb | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical source2013 retrospective quoting Ray Didinger’s saved 1999 pre-draft notes; original document not separately available Exact original publication date not verified | Combine recordMockDraftable combine measurements; no non-combine asterisk |
| Joe Burrow | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourceRetrospective republication explicitly quoting Lance Zierlein's 2020 NFL.com scouting report; NOT a newly discovered 2020 page 2025-04-02 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Philip Rivers | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcecontemporaneous pre-draft reporting, 2004-02-20 2004-02-20 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Russell Wilson | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcecontemporaneous independent draft profile, 2012 Exact original publication date not verified | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Tony Romo | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcedraft verification only Exact original publication date not verified | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Carson Palmer | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourcecontemporaneous pre-draft selection reporting, 2003-04-24 Body dateline April 24, 2003; header April 23, 2003 conflicts | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Dak Prescott | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourceCharlie Campbell's pre-draft analysis, surviving legacy page with later modification indicator 2016; exact original date not recovered | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Eli Manning | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical source2017 republication of Ernie Accorsi's original college scouting report Republished April 24, 2017; original report date unverified | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
| Jared Goff | Draft / signing recordPrimary NFL, team or college source; checked November 13, 2026 | Scouting / historical sourceOriginal Chargers editorial prospect profile; expressly not front-office/coaching opinion Published March 16, 2016 | Combine recordPFR combine data distributed by nflverse; heights whole-inch precision |
Wilson’s 2012 Combine height is reported as 5 ft 10⅝ in by official team reporting, while the cohort baseline records the rounded 5 ft 11 in. See his profile for both sources. No original weigh-in sheets have been obtained. These source types are not silently equated.
McNabb and Romo: original pre-draft reports not verified. Rivers and Palmer: limited contemporaneous coverage, not full reports. Uniform college-start counts and athletic-testing figures contain unresolved differences; no cohort-wide totals are presented. Goff’s vertical jump is disputed: Chargers 27.5 inches versus 49ers 27 inches and Rams 27.0 inches; no definitive value is used for comparison. Team biographies and draft-trade histories should be checked alongside final selection records.
Each photo on the homepage has its creator, source link and Creative Commons license beside it. Original photo files are unchanged; CSS display crops are disclosed. NCAA scores and CBS analysis are outbound publisher resources, not our live data feed or rankings.
Return to the site →Updated November 15, 2026. Tier 4 contains Andrew Luck, Trevor Lawrence and Kirk Cousins. The current 29-player dataset supersedes the dated 28-player audits below; historical source files and snapshots remain unchanged. Current 29-player evidence.
Apply the highest qualifying tier first. Only AP NFL MVP and AP All-Pro honors count; First- and Second-Team All-Pro recognition in the same season counts as one season. MVP finishes require actual votes, including tied ranks. Conference championships and Super Bowls count starts at Quarterback, not roster membership. Retired Quarterbacks ordinarily need 100 NFL regular-season starts; active Quarterbacks do not. Pro Bowls have zero weight.
Evaluation cutoff: end of the 2025 NFL season, including its postseason and awards. The 2026 season is excluded. Future season updates wait until the postseason and awards are complete.
3 AP MVP awards (2007, 2010, 2017) and 7 Super Bowl wins as starting QB.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile5 AP MVP awards (2003, 2004, 2008, 2009, 2013) and 2 Super Bowl wins as starting QB.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile4 AP MVP awards (2011, 2014, 2020, 2021) and a Super Bowl XLV win as starting QB.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2 AP MVP awards (2018, 2022) and 3 Super Bowl wins as starting QB through the cutoff.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile5 AP All-Pro seasons: 2006, 2008, 2009, 2011 and 2018.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileAP MVP in 2019 and 2023; no Super Bowl victory as starting QB through the cutoff, so not Tier 1.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2024 AP NFL MVP.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2025 AP NFL MVP.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2016 AP NFL MVP.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2015 AP NFL MVP.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2 Super Bowl MVP awards: XLII and XLVI.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile3 Super Bowl starts: 2005, 2008 and 2010 seasons.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2019 AP Second-Team All-Pro.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile3rd in 2009 AP MVP voting, with 2 votes. This is the 2009 result, not 2008.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2nd in 2000 AP MVP voting.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2014 AP Second-Team All-Pro.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2023 AP Second-Team All-Pro and 2nd in AP MVP voting.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2015 AP Second-Team All-Pro.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2022 AP Second-Team All-Pro.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2025 AP Second-Team All-Pro.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile2nd in 2004 AP MVP voting, with 1 vote. This route does not claim a 2010 AP All-Pro selection.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileTied 3rd in 2016 AP MVP voting, with 6 votes.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile3 AFC Championship starts: 2008, 2011 and 2012 seasons.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileTwo top-5 AP MVP finishes: 4th in 2022 and 4th in 2024.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile5th in 2024 AP MVP voting (47 points), plus NFC Championship starts in the 2018 and 2023 seasons. No 2018 MVP votes are claimed.
Achievement reference ↗ · Profile4th in 2023 AP MVP voting (97 points), plus NFC Championship starts in the 2022 and 2023 seasons. The injury-shortened 2022 appearance still counts as a start.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileEditorial eye-test exception. Not claimed to qualify through an achievement route. Also exempted from the retired-player 100-start floor; he had 86 regular-season starts.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileEditorial eye-test exception. Not claimed to qualify through an achievement route; a single 5th-place AP MVP finish alone is insufficient.
Achievement reference ↗ · ProfileThis is a selected editorial cohort, not an exhaustive or purely mechanical classification. Chad Pennington and Carson Wentz are excluded by FindMeMyQB’s eye-test decision. Daunte Culpepper, Jimmy Garoppolo and Sam Darnold are not included in the current list. Kurt Warner is specifically excluded because his initial NFL signing was before 1998, despite his 1998 regular-season debut; this does not change the debut-date eligibility rule.
Editorial eye-test inclusion in Tier 4, selected by FindMeMyQB. Not claimed to qualify through an achievement route.
Sourced college, draft and measurement profile →Eight additional profiles now contain source-labeled core records. College raw counts take precedence over inconsistent prose percentages. Combine, other pre-draft records and retrospective scouting material are explicitly distinguished. This earlier update is superseded by the full 28 harmonization below.
Homepage/profile comparisons now cover all 28. Older bowl-excluding records are reconstructed where supported. All original audit files remain preserved in source history. Each row exposes source URLs and scope.
Full dataset with evidence · Similarity denominators and exceptions
Historical audit of the previous 28-player group. The current group has 29 players; use the current evidence downloads below. The November 15 addition is documented separately.
The five underlying NCAA passing inputs (completions, attempts, yards, passing touchdowns and interceptions) were rechecked for all 28 Quarterbacks, including the older postseason addbacks. All 28 measurement pairs and calculated BMIs, birth-date ages, and the 21 similarity-card calculations were checked separately. The detailed Cal career table resolved Jared Goff’s yardage to 12,200, with 7.78 yards per attempt; conflicting biography prose is not used.
Coverage is not a claim that all sources are equally precise. Measurements mix Combine, prospect and rookie records. Some starts use official totals or documented season derivations rather than a newly rebuilt every-game ledger. Whole-year prospect ages include secondary reporting. The 2027 board remains a November 13 snapshot, not a live feed. Statistical similarity is not evidence of predictive accuracy without a comparison group.
Reconstructed QB-start total: 33 (7 in 2015, 13 in 2016 and 13 in 2017), supported by the Louisville starting-lineup ledger plus bowl start and the Ravens 2018 media guide. Conflicting primary records remain: the Louisville biography says eight QB starts in 2015 and the Vikings profile says 34 career QB starts. Auburn was a non-QB start; sources describe the position differently (WR in the lineup chart, running back in the Louisville biography). We do not treat the 33-versus-34 discrepancy as conclusively resolved. Both totals exceed 25 College QB starts.
All-college totals now include verified post-high-school junior-college seasons: Aaron Rodgers at Butte (2002), Cam Newton at Blinn (2009), and Josh Allen at Reedley (2014). NCAA subtotals and junior-college rows remain separate in each profile and the JSON/CSV downloads. Combined rates are recomputed from additive totals, not averaged.
Rodgers’ 11 Butte starts are reconstructed from contemporary college starter records and official Cal starts. Allen’s six Reedley starts are supported by the school Hall of Fame program and corroborated reporting; conflicting appearance totals are not used as starts. Newton’s 12 Blinn starts are explicitly documented by contemporary reporting. Competition levels and eras are not adjusted. The other 26 current college histories have no identified JUCO stint.