Assigned under FindMeMyQB’s published achievement routes and explicit editorial exceptions. This is not an NFL designation or a validated predictive score. Pre-draft evidence is kept separate from NFL accomplishments.
Evidence collection in progress
This profile presents sourced paraphrases where available, not a complete scouting record. Historical republications are labeled. Missing data is not a negative evaluation.
Why Tier 1?
4 AP MVP awards (2011, 2014, 2020, 2021) and a Super Bowl XLV win as starting QB.
At least 2 AP NFL MVP awards AND at least 1 Super Bowl victory as the starting Quarterback.
Evaluation cutoff: end of the 2025 NFL season, including its postseason and awards. The 2026 season is excluded. Future season updates wait until the postseason and awards are complete.
Not yet verified. No pro-day or college listing is substituted for Combine measurements.
Compare the evidence.
Shared traits must be supported by comparable records, not inferred from success in the NFL. The core tables compare all 29 players using the same disclosed all-college passing and Quarterback-start definitions. Pre-draft and rookie-fallback measurement sources are labeled individually; film and advanced-stat archives are not complete.
Experience
College starts, seasons, age and development.
Production
Completion rate, passing efficiency, touchdowns and interceptions, with season and competition context.
Background
Recruiting history, scheme, responsibilities and supporting cast.
Physical profile
Source-labeled Combine measurements and testing; missing values shown honestly.
The cohort table contains source-labeled descriptive comparisons. No predictive conclusions have been validated, and missing or conflicting records are not treated as negative results.
Source and interpretation policy.
Scouting summaries are paraphrases of the linked evaluator or reporter, not a consensus or verbatim report. A later republication date is not the original scouting date. This profile does not use an invented numerical scouting grade.
Combined NCAA + junior-college totals. Original NCAA subtotal and JUCO row preserved separately. Rates recomputed from summed numerators/denominators; not era- or competition-adjusted. Butte starts 11 reconstructed from explicit contemporary college starter record and official Cal starts, not merely games played. Some secondary stories say 26 TD/11-1, contradicting primary Cal and NFL 28 TD/10-1. Prefer official additive totals. Cal bio erroneous 16.2 yards/completion conflicts with 2,408 / 164; recompute 14.68, never copy 16.2.
Measurement source period: 2005 contemporary Combine-era prospect report. The exact height/weight measurement date is not established in this dataset. A report’s publication date is not necessarily the measurement date. BMI is calculated from this same recorded height and weight.
6 ft 2 in · 223 lb · BMI 28.6. 2005 contemporary Combine-era prospect report. Status: source verified.
Combine tests, pro days and rookie listings are different records. Each observation below identifies its source period; an unknown is never zero. BMI is calculated from the listed height and weight, not body-fat percentage.
2005 Combine; ESPN/NBC retrospective reporting selected source report. Selected 10.125 in from ESPN and the NBC 2017 report explicitly attributing this figure to the Scouting Combine, per the requested source preference. NBC 2014 reports 9.38 in and MockDraftable 9.375 in; the substantial discrepancy remains unresolved, not averaged. This is a selected attributed report, not original-sheet verification. Source 1 ↗ · Source 2 ↗ · Source 3 ↗ · Source 4 ↗
Arm Length
Not Verified
2005 NFL pre-draft prospect measurement not verified.
Wingspan
Not Verified
2005 NFL pre-draft prospect measurement not verified.
40-Yard Dash
Not Verified
2005 NFL Scouting Combine source specific timing. Source 1 ↗
derived from listed pre-draft height/weight, not a body-fat measure derived. Derived from the selected source-specific height/weight pair, not body-fat percentage. Source 1 ↗
Missing or conflicting measurements stay unverified. These observations describe this cohort; they do not establish that a physical trait predicts NFL success.