Search all quarterback recordsComparison Lab

1927 NFL Debut Cohort (Pre-Draft Era)

Source-backed pre-NFL research. Unverified values remain unavailable; coverage and source differences are retained with each player. These records do not expand the 29-player franchise baseline.

Benny Friedman

Michigan · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Friedman began NFL play as Cleveland's Quarterback in 1927 after his Michigan career.

Benny Friedman, 1926 Michigan photograph
1926 Michigan photograph
1927 Michiganensian; photographer unidentified · Public domain (US, expired) · Photo source
Unmodified archival photograph; displayed to fit.
College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

College source ↗

College source ↗

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Friedman began NFL play as Cleveland's Quarterback in 1927 after his Michigan career. Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗ Source 4 ↗

Last documented college playing season 1926; numerical passing/rushing totals unresolved.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1924 · MichiganN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · MichiganN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1926 · MichiganN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗ Source 4 ↗

Source Differences

Professional completion and yardage totals must not be presented as college production. Full college passing and rushing totals remain unresolved.

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗ Source 4 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗ Source 4 ↗

Bill Donohoe

Carnegie Tech · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Donohoe entered the NFL with Frankford in 1927, with Quarterback included among his historical positions.

College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Donohoe entered the NFL with Frankford in 1927, with Quarterback included among his historical positions. Source 1 ↗

Final college playing season unresolved; see college chronology and source differences.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1924 · Carnegie TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · Carnegie TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1926 · Carnegie TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗

Source Differences

College chronology reaches 1926, but original contemporary game reports have not been inspected; final playing season remains unresolved.

Source 1 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.
  • Rights-cleared portrait still under review.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗

Dave Mishel

Brown · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Mishel entered the NFL with Providence in 1927 as a back. His later Cleveland service in 1931 includes Quarterback; this is not a claim he was a rookie Quarterback.

College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Mishel entered the NFL with Providence in 1927 as a back. His later Cleveland service in 1931 includes Quarterback; this is not a claim he was a rookie Quarterback. Source 1 ↗

Last documented college playing season 1926; numerical passing/rushing totals unresolved.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1923 · BrownN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1924 · BrownN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · BrownN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1926 · BrownN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗

Source Differences

Professional career-game totals differ between databases; college totals remain unresolved.

Source 1 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.
  • Rights-cleared portrait still under review.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗

Dinty Moore

Lafayette · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Walter Stanley (Dinty) Moore entered the NFL with Pottsville in 1927, including historical Quarterback duties.

College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Walter Stanley (Dinty) Moore entered the NFL with Pottsville in 1927, including historical Quarterback duties. Source 1 ↗

Final college playing season unresolved; see college chronology and source differences.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1923 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1924 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗

Source Differences

Last verified college letter year is 1925; final playing season is not established.

Source 1 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.
  • Rights-cleared portrait still under review.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗

Doug Wycoff

Georgia Tech · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Wycoff entered the NFL with the New York Giants in 1927. His 1929 Staten Island positions include Quarterback; earlier 1926 Newark service was AFL, not NFL.

Doug Wycoff, 1926 Georgia Tech baseball photograph
1926 Georgia Tech baseball photograph
Lane Brothers / The Technique · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo source
Unmodified archival photograph; displayed to fit.
College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Wycoff entered the NFL with the New York Giants in 1927. His 1929 Staten Island positions include Quarterback; earlier 1926 Newark service was AFL, not NFL. Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Last documented college playing season 1925; numerical passing/rushing totals unresolved.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1922 · Georgia TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1923 · Georgia TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1924 · Georgia TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · Georgia TechN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Source Differences

Historical multi-position back, not exclusively a passing Quarterback. Professional totals do not establish college starts or production.

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Frank Kirkleski

Lafayette · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Kirkleski entered the NFL with Pottsville in 1927. A college halfback, his professional positions include historical Quarterback.

College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

College source ↗

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Kirkleski entered the NFL with Pottsville in 1927. A college halfback, his professional positions include historical Quarterback. Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Last documented college playing season 1926; numerical passing/rushing totals unresolved.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1923 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1924 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1926 · LafayetteN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Source Differences

Lafayette's team record is not an individual college starts total.

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.
  • Rights-cleared portrait still under review.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Harlan Carr

Syracuse · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Syracuse identifies Carr as an NFL Quarterback for Buffalo in 1927.

Harlan Carr, Syracuse football action, November 26, 1925
Syracuse football action, November 26, 1925
New York Daily News; photographer unidentified · Public domain (US, expired) · Photo source
Unmodified archival photograph; displayed to fit.
College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

College source ↗

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Syracuse identifies Carr as an NFL Quarterback for Buffalo in 1927. Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Last documented college playing season 1926; numerical passing/rushing totals unresolved.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1924 · SyracuseN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · SyracuseN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1926 · SyracuseN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Source Differences

Undated professional height and weight are not dated college measurements or workout results.

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Ken Mercer

Simpson · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Mercer entered the NFL with Frankford in 1927, with historical Quarterback among his positions.

College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Mercer entered the NFL with Frankford in 1927, with historical Quarterback among his positions. Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Final college playing season unresolved; see college chronology and source differences.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1922 · SimpsonN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1923 · SimpsonN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1924 · SimpsonN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · SimpsonN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Source Differences

Roster listings do not establish final playing season. Dates associated with other sports must not replace football chronology.

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.
  • Rights-cleared portrait still under review.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗

Wes Fry

Iowa · Not applicable: entered before the NFL draft

Pre-1927 NFL-debut college record. Draft selection and age at draft do not apply. Outside the fixed 29-player baseline.

Listed position: Historical NFL Quarterback/back hybrid. Fry entered the NFL with the New York Yankees in 1927, including historical Quarterback duties. His 1926 Yankees season was in the AFL, not the NFL.

College Passing & Starts
Completions
N/A
Attempts
N/A
Passing Yards
N/A
Passing TD
N/A
Interceptions
N/A
College QB Starts
N/A

Complete combined college passing/rushing totals remain unresolved. Missing values are unknown, not zero; NFL production is not substituted.

Strict college Quarterback starts unverified; appearances and team schedules are not starts.

College source ↗

College source ↗

College source ↗

Draft-Era Measurements & Testing
Height (ft / in)
Not available
Weight (lb)
Not available
Hands (in)
Not available
Arms (in)
Not available
Wingspan (in)
Not available
40 Yards (s)
Not available
10-Yard Split (s)
Not available
20-Yard Split (s)
Not available
Three-Cone (s)
Not available
20-Yard Shuttle (s)
Not available
Vertical (in)
Not available
Broad Jump (in)
Not available

Fry entered the NFL with the New York Yankees in 1927, including historical Quarterback duties. His 1926 Yankees season was in the AFL, not the NFL. Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Last documented college playing season 1925; numerical passing/rushing totals unresolved.

College Season-by-Season
Year / SchoolGames / StartsCmp / AttPass YdsTD / INTRush Att / Yds / TD
1923 · IowaN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1924 · IowaN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A
1925 · IowaN/A / N/AN/A / N/AN/AN/A / N/AN/A / N/A / N/A

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Source Differences

Combined professional league totals are not NFL-only totals and never substitute for college statistics.

Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗

Record Coverage
  • Full college career/final-season passing and rushing totals, individual games and strict QB starts unresolved.
  • No verified dated college/workout measurements, modern Combine or Pro Day tests.
  • Rights-cleared portrait still under review.

Draft/signing verification: Source 1 ↗ Source 2 ↗ Source 3 ↗